MD&A · 2024
In this section4 topics
Overview of Operations
Overview of Operations
In January, Charn Issara Residence Co., Ltd. (subsidiary “CIR”) launched The Sky Series project, a 4-unit luxury villa project worth 1,000 million baht located in the Sri Panwa Phuket project area.
In April, Sri Panwa Management Co., Ltd. (subsidiary “SPM”) received approval from the trust to postpone the payment of the rental fee for the second investment asset in the trust in the amount of 108.44 million baht according to the rental payment plan, which is scheduled to be paid between April 2024 and December 2028.
In May, the company registered Issara Naporn Co., Ltd. (subsidiary “ISN”) with a registered capital of 100 million baht. ISD called for payment of shares in May in the amount of 70 million, of which the company holds 59.99 percent, to be a real estate development company for residential projects under the Sri Panwa Lagoon project. It also registered Issara Wipaphon Co., Ltd. (subsidiary “ISV”) with a registered capital of 50 million baht. ISV called for payment of shares in May in the amount of 25 million baht, of which the company holds 49.99 percent to be a real estate development company, residential houses under the Sri Panwa Place project
In August, the company issued 2 sets of debentures, 1st set with a term of 1 year and 6 months, worth 209.10 million baht, and 2nd set with a term of 2 years and 6 months, worth 400.50 million baht, to repay the original debentures.
In December, Bang Bok Real Estate Investment Fund, in which the company holds 17.56 percent of the investment units in the fund, was converted into an Issara Real Estate Investment Trust and exchanged the investment units into the original fund with Issara Trust units on December 3, 2024.
Operating Results & Financial Condition
Operating Results & Profitability
Operating results and profitability
Performance Results
Income
Charn Issara Development Public Company Limited and its subsidiaries had total revenue from operations in 2024 of 2,942.56 million baht, an increase of 691.81 million baht or 30.74 percent from 2023. The change in revenue was due to revenue from the sale of real estate in 2024 of 1,705.16 million baht, an increase of 910.97 million baht or 114.70 percent from the previous year due to the transfer of ownership of condominium units in The Issara Sathorn and Sasara Hua Hin projects, which were completed in late 2023 and have begun to transfer ownership to customers continuously, housing estates in the Baan Issara Bangna and Issara projects Residence Rama 9. While in 2023, the Company had a profit from changing the payment period of the past outstanding rental of the Sri Panwa Hotel 2 property lease agreement of 32.4 million baht from receiving approval to postpone the payment of the rental of 184.5 million baht by paying in installments of 60 installments until July 2028. The Company had a profit from receiving an exemption of the rental fee of the Sri Panwa Hotel 1 and 3 property funds from the Sri Panwa Hotel Real Estate Investment Trust (REIT) of 42.3 million baht from being able to comply with the conditions set by REIT, and had a profit from changing the lease agreement of 116.1 million baht from canceling the lease of the Sri Panwa Hotel 2 property from REIT because the lease agreement had expired and SPM did not wish to renew the lease agreement with the same conditions.
Gross Profit
• The Company had a gross profit margin from the sale of real estate in 2024 of 31.27 percent, which was an increase of 1.52 percent from 2023. The increase in gross profit margin was due to the transfer of ownership of condominiums, especially large-sized units of the Company.
• The Company had a gross profit margin from the office rental and service business in the Charn Issara Tower 1 and 2 buildings and units in the Issara Lad Phrao Condominium in 2024 of 43.93 percent, an increase of 8.23 from 2023 due to the gradual increase in rent and the electricity charge rate from the increase in the FT rate.
• The Company had a gross profit margin from the hotel business in 2024 of 24.61 percent, which was an increase of 2.12 percent from 2023 due to the Company's better cost management and recognition of lower rental costs under the investment property lease agreement in Sri Panwa Hotel 2 due to the request for a change in the terms of the lease agreement. This resulted in a better gross profit margin from the hotel business.
• The Company had a gross profit margin from sales of goods in 2024 of 4.34 percent, which was slightly lower than in 2023 by 0.50 percent, mainly due to the volatility of oil prices.
Expenses
• Distribution and administrative expenses in 2024 were 736.15 million baht, an increase of 13.46 percent compared to 2023. The main reason for the increase was the increase in expenses related to the sale of real estate, such as specific business tax, transfer fee and commission.
• Loss from financial derivatives during 2024, the Company entered into contracts that were in the nature of financial derivatives and had to be measured at fair value, which the contract value was higher than fair value, therefore, a loss of 30.1 million baht had to be recognized.
• Finance expenses in 2024 were 418.68 million baht, an increase of 5.33 percent compared to 2023 because some of the Company's projects were completed in 2024, so such finance expenses could not be recognized as part of the construction cost in addition to the increase in interest rates during the year.
Net profit / (loss)
The Company had an operating loss in 2024 of 289.90 million baht, with a net loss attributable to shareholders of the Company of 264.36 million baht, and a loss reduction of 71.51 million baht compared to 2023, resulting in a net loss attributable to shareholders of the Company per share of 0.2478 baht per share.
Financial status
Assets
As of December 31, 2024, the Company had total assets of 10,849.69 million baht, a decrease of 1,970.38 million baht or 15.37 percent from December 31, 2023, mainly due to a decrease in the cost of real estate development projects for sale of 816.6 million baht. During the year, the cost of real estate development projects for sale decreased by 816.6 million baht from the transfer of ownership of real estate, mainly condominium units, The Issara Sathorn condominium project, Sasara Hua Hin project, Baan Issara Bangna project to customers during the period and the transfer of land classification in The Issara Chiang Mai Phase 2 project and some land in Phang Nga province as land awaiting development, net of the development cost of the Baan Issara Bangna project and new projects under development. The Company has restricted bank deposits, decreased by 994.5 million baht from the Company's repayment of debentures. Due in the amount of 950.0 million baht on January 2, 2024, property, plant and equipment decreased by 262.5 million baht from the depreciation of buildings and equipment, net of building renovations and purchases of materials and equipment during the period. In addition, during the period, the accounting classification was transferred by transferring land to real estate development costs of 33.2 million baht and reversing the revaluation of land of 116.0 million baht from the accounts, even though the Company's investment in associates increased by 54.4 million baht from the investment in Good Neighbors Biotechnology Co., Ltd. and Issara Naporn Co., Ltd., net of the recognition of losses during the year of the associates. Right-of-use assets increased by 32.8 million baht from the recognition of assets under lease contracts in SPM 2, net of the amortization of assets under the right-of-use during the period. And land awaiting development increased by 106.6 million baht from the transfer of land classification of The Issara Chiang Mai Phase 2 project and some land in Phang Nga Province from the cost of real estate development for sale because the Company has delayed the construction of the project.
Liabilities
As of December 31, 2024, the Company had total liabilities of 8,600.88 million baht, a decrease of 1,603.50 million baht or 15.71 percent from December 31, 2023, mainly due to a decrease in debentures of 847.10 million baht, trade and other current payables of 920.6 million baht from payments for construction work, land costs, and rental payments under the SPM2 lease agreement, which was approved to postpone rental payments in the past during the year, and loans from other companies of 290.3 million baht from repayments of loans under the agreement when the Company transferred ownership of real estate to customers. Even though loans from financial institutions increased by 346.5 million baht and loans from related persons and businesses increased by 184.8 million baht from real estate development for sale during the year, such as the Sasa Hua Hin condominium project, the Independent Bangna housing project, and new projects under development, along with during the year. Lease liabilities increased by 52.0 million baht from the recognition of lease liabilities in SPM 2, net of rental payments under the contract, especially the lease of real estate in Sri Panwa Hotel.
Shareholders' Equity
As of December 31, 2024, the Company had total shareholders equity of THB 2,248.81 million, a decrease of THB 366.88 million, mainly due to the recognition of losses during 2024 and the recognition the devaluation of the Company's non-current financial assets.
Debt Securities with Financial Ratio Requirements
Debt Securities with Financial Ratio Requirements Issued?
Yes
Can the Company Maintain the Reported Financial Ratios?
Yes
Explanation
Financial conditions of the issuance of debt instruments The issuer of the debentures will maintain the ratio of "interest-bearing debt" to "equity" (Interest-Bearing Debt to Equity Ratio) at a ratio not exceeding 3.75:1 (three point seven five to one) as of the end of the quarterly accounting period or the end of the fiscal year of the issuer. Specifically, debts that are subject to interest payments (excluding debts under lease contracts) according to the consolidated financial statements of the bond issuer according to the figures appearing in the quarterly consolidated financial statements or annual consolidated financial statements of the bond issuer.
As of the end of the annual consolidated financial statements, the Company can maintain the financial ratios.
Factors That May Affect Financial Condition
Factors or Incidents That May Materially Affect Financial Condition
In order for the management to operate in accordance with the goals and policies and for the operations to be effective in accordance with the Company's plans, the overall risk management process must be monitored to be at an appropriate level, including the determination, assessment, reduction, monitoring of risks and reporting such results to the Audit Committee and the Board of Directors. In order to be consistent with the risk management policy, the Risk Management Committee has established a policy for risk management and management systems and for the operations to be effective in accordance with the Company's plans and reporting such results to the Audit Committee and the Board of Directors, with tools to identify, reduce, monitor and report risks related to the operations of the Company and its subsidiaries. The significant risk factors for the operations of the Company and its subsidiaries that will be considered are:
1) Risks from land procurement for project development Risk issues include EIA permission, construction cost control, and construction delays. Procurement of potential land is an important factor in developing real estate projects to meet consumer demand and is an important factor in creating success for the project. Over the past several years, Thailand has invested in developing public utilities and infrastructure in both Bangkok and nearby provincial areas, including the construction of electric trains and road expansions, resulting in increased urban expansion and real estate development projects. This has led to increased demand for land to support business and residential growth, as well as speculation in land trading, which has resulted in increased land prices, especially in areas with electric train construction and extensions, business districts, tourist cities, and provinces with special economic zones. Higher land prices have become an important cost in developing real estate projects and are an important risk factor that the company has taken action to control. The company places great importance on land procurement for project development. It has a plan to survey and establish good partnerships with quality networks that have the potential to procure land in good locations at reasonable and fair prices. The company also has a project review committee that acts as an important mechanism to help consider the feasibility of the project and provide opinions before making a decision before investing in land purchases, so that the company can develop new projects efficiently and appropriately. In addition, the company has no policy of accumulating more land than necessary to prevent liquidity management risks and financial risks. The Company has a team and working mechanism that can take care of the suitability of land procurement to be at a level appropriate for the Company's business.
2) Risks from project construction Construction management is a very important task in developing various projects because there are uncertainties that may occur during the operation, both controllable and uncontrollable. There are many risks that may occur from construction, such as the issue of increasing construction material prices, which change according to the prices of various raw materials involved in the supply chain of changes in the domestic and international economic system, the issue of shortage of skilled labor and increasing labor costs, the issue of selecting potential and qualified contractors who are skilled in construction management to be in line with the budget and plan. The company has tried to manage and control risk factors that may cause such impacts by bidding for construction work and selecting large, reputable contractors who are skilled and accepted in the market and have reliable construction work records to be the project contractors, and using the lump sum hiring method for the entire project, which helps reduce the risk of fluctuations in material prices and increased labor costs. In addition, the company will contact many distributors to compete in offering materials, allowing the project to get good material prices and enabling project cost control before construction begins and before setting the selling price to customers. The company has experts and experience in project management to help supervise and control contractors who accept construction work, coordinate and control, and report progress of the construction plan on a weekly basis, allowing the management to be aware of construction results, problems, and obstacles. To be able to jointly provide assistance in solving problems and planning so that construction proceeds as planned and achieves the goals of success, and is completed on time for delivery to customers.
3) Risk from inventory With the economic slowdown, which has been affected by the problems of the Thai and global economies, Thai politics, low agricultural product prices, drought problems, high household debt, and increasingly stringent credit measures by financial institutions, these are all factors that affect consumer confidence and purchasing power, resulting in a delay in the decision to invest and/or buy a home. In addition, the intense competition in the real estate business has caused entrepreneurs to be cautious and delay the launch of new projects in order to monitor the situation and quickly clear out existing inventory. The company has expertise in the real estate business for over 30 years and has developed residential projects including single houses and condominiums, 5-star hotels, and office buildings, with a target group of high-end customers. The company has a policy of selling projects by requiring customers to pay a down payment of no less than 20-30%, so most of the company's customers are not affected by the stringent credit measures of financial institutions that have been announced for this group of customers. The company has hired reputable sales agencies and sales teams and has studied consumer behavior and needs to plan sales strategies and continuously market in order to meet consumer needs as much as possible and create a clear difference and selling point, including checking the quality of after-sales service and taking care of customers to achieve maximum satisfaction. The company also has a plan to expand sales to foreign customers who are interested in buying or investing in real estate. To help the company achieve its sales targets.
4) Risk from increased competition in the industry Currently, the real estate business is highly competitive due to the increasing number of entrepreneurs, both small and large, in Bangkok and its vicinity, especially in convenient locations near mass transit systems, which is a result of increased investment from the government sector in developing the country's infrastructure. Many entrepreneurs are competing with a variety of strategies, such as organizing promotions, discounts, giving away various free gifts, etc. However, the Company has a business policy and competitive strategy that is different from its competitors, both in terms of paying attention to the details of outstanding project design, understanding the needs of residents, having a unique identity that is different from competitors in the same level, having complete functions that meet consumer needs, and selecting good quality materials. In addition, the Company's project developments are spread across many major cities, such as Chiang Mai, Phuket, Hua Hin, Phang Nga, etc., allowing the Company to have a variety of customer groups, including those who want to buy for residence, those who buy for vacation rentals, and those who rent out. It also creates a credible image that is accepted and trusted by consumers. The Company is confident that for the reasons mentioned above, the Company's projects can compete amidst the increasingly competitive real estate industry today.
5) Risk from changes in government policies, laws and related regulations In developing real estate projects, the Company must comply with relevant laws, regulations and rules, such as the Land Allocation Act, Condominium Act, City Planning Regulations, Hotel Act, etc. If the Company is unable to comply in full, it may affect the control of construction costs and the estimated project development period, which may delay cash flow from the transfer of ownership from the sale of the project. However, as the Company has been a real estate developer for over 30 years, it knows and understands the relevant rules and regulations very well. In addition, there are agencies that monitor changes related to the regulations at all times. In addition, before developing each project, the Company studies the relevant regulations together with specialized consultants to ensure that the project can be developed correctly.
